Interesting post about Canadian healthcare
Moderators: thunder, fruitbat, Chari910, Marie, Helen8, Gillian, kjshd05, catloveyes, LadyLucius
- Hilary the Touched
- Site Registrant
- Posts: 7197
- Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:11 pm
- Location: The Frozen North
- Contact:
Grannybear, we're grateful you're here to share your story with us!
Wolfsaver, you make some excellent points--some might have argued against the expense of hip replacement for a woman of advanced years, but those surgeries have obviously had a profound impact for your aunt, and allowed her to avoid more expensive life changes.
As I said, I think elective euthanasia should be permitted--assisted suicide. People have been 'playing God' for centuries, diminishing and removing causes of death (smallpox, antibiotics). I think a little laxity in the other direction is warranted.
I'm not sure how to settle all the questions about people who aren't able (i.e., comatose) to provide informed consent . . . but that's a question for next of kin even now, so not, I think, a radical change . . .
Wolfsaver, you make some excellent points--some might have argued against the expense of hip replacement for a woman of advanced years, but those surgeries have obviously had a profound impact for your aunt, and allowed her to avoid more expensive life changes.
As I said, I think elective euthanasia should be permitted--assisted suicide. People have been 'playing God' for centuries, diminishing and removing causes of death (smallpox, antibiotics). I think a little laxity in the other direction is warranted.
I'm not sure how to settle all the questions about people who aren't able (i.e., comatose) to provide informed consent . . . but that's a question for next of kin even now, so not, I think, a radical change . . .
Have you ever heard of the movie Logan's Run made in 1976?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan's_Run_(1976_film)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan's_Run_(1976_film)
- Hilary the Touched
- Site Registrant
- Posts: 7197
- Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:11 pm
- Location: The Frozen North
- Contact:
Me too. I just remembered it when reading some of the previous posts.
Conspiracy theroy, eh, not what I meant. No conspiracy just humanity becoming to relaxed with certain aspects of medical care for certain
people like the elder or the little ones whose parents could care less about them. Or maybe the homeless or ones with mental problems that start to be too much trouble.
Indirect or crooked line from universal healthcare to
mandatory death at any age........not so sure. Maybe not for us oldies but what about the future? Riduclous..... maybe, maybe not.
Who here knows exactly what the whole universal healthcare proposition
is about..... or for that matter exactly what it contains? I know I don't
And who will exactly make the judgement call for you (as in plural) or me? The Federal government?
We have come along way from the 70's and now we are looking at how we became so dependent on oil products. I know, I know the oil doesn't have anything to do with this subject but we might look back in 20 yrs or so and wonder why we became so dependent on our government for universal health care. What is universal health care anyway?Is it for the unborn up to the very old?
Maybe we need to think about this subject. That's all I am saying.
Conspiracy theroy, eh, not what I meant. No conspiracy just humanity becoming to relaxed with certain aspects of medical care for certain
people like the elder or the little ones whose parents could care less about them. Or maybe the homeless or ones with mental problems that start to be too much trouble.
Indirect or crooked line from universal healthcare to
mandatory death at any age........not so sure. Maybe not for us oldies but what about the future? Riduclous..... maybe, maybe not.
Who here knows exactly what the whole universal healthcare proposition
is about..... or for that matter exactly what it contains? I know I don't
And who will exactly make the judgement call for you (as in plural) or me? The Federal government?
We have come along way from the 70's and now we are looking at how we became so dependent on oil products. I know, I know the oil doesn't have anything to do with this subject but we might look back in 20 yrs or so and wonder why we became so dependent on our government for universal health care. What is universal health care anyway?Is it for the unborn up to the very old?
Maybe we need to think about this subject. That's all I am saying.
What is universal health care anyway?Is it for the unborn up to the very old?
Look up "universal" in the dictionary. That would include prenatal to geriatric. Everybody.
Indirect or crooked line from universal healthcare to
mandatory death at any age........not so sure.
So, it's okay that people die unnecessarily because they can't afford to go to the doctor or to pay for their treatment as they don't have health insurance or because their insurance company dumped them on trumped-up "pre-existing condition" charges?
Look up "universal" in the dictionary. That would include prenatal to geriatric. Everybody.
Indirect or crooked line from universal healthcare to
mandatory death at any age........not so sure.
So, it's okay that people die unnecessarily because they can't afford to go to the doctor or to pay for their treatment as they don't have health insurance or because their insurance company dumped them on trumped-up "pre-existing condition" charges?
- Hilary the Touched
- Site Registrant
- Posts: 7197
- Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:11 pm
- Location: The Frozen North
- Contact:
I find it completely maddening that the people so passionately opposing universal health care (yeah, HEALTH CARE FOR EVERYONE) are so often the ones worst served by our current system (the poor, the under-insured or uninsured).
As I quoted above, for those reading as well as writing, ""I can never understand why right wingers are always worried about the government making their health care decisions when they are perfectly willing to let insurance companies do it."
So let's review:
Allow healthcare decisions to be made by people working for huge corporations strongly invested in MAKING A PROFIT FROM YOUR HEALTHCARE, or made by your physicians and the entity currently responsible for providing care to the indigent, the U.S. military, retired military, and Congress, all of whom do currently suffer under a single-payer plan??
Who here is using a commercial insurance plan? And how many among you can honestly say you've NEVER had to change physicians because your old doctor isn't affiliated with the new insurance plan that your employer offers? How many have never had a test or treatment denied by your insurance company, even when your doctor urged you to have it done?
The United States spends more per capita on healthcare than any other country, and yet has higher rates of infant mortality than FORTY-ONE OTHER COUNTRIES (I got this information from that socialist hotbed of pinko propaganda, the CIA World Factbook), including paragons of progressiveness like Slovenia and, um, Cuba. Also Canada and the United Kingdom, two unfortunate nations currently languishing under a single-payer plan.
I know it's charming to believe it, but just because something is American doesn't always make it the best.
As I quoted above, for those reading as well as writing, ""I can never understand why right wingers are always worried about the government making their health care decisions when they are perfectly willing to let insurance companies do it."
So let's review:
Allow healthcare decisions to be made by people working for huge corporations strongly invested in MAKING A PROFIT FROM YOUR HEALTHCARE, or made by your physicians and the entity currently responsible for providing care to the indigent, the U.S. military, retired military, and Congress, all of whom do currently suffer under a single-payer plan??
Who here is using a commercial insurance plan? And how many among you can honestly say you've NEVER had to change physicians because your old doctor isn't affiliated with the new insurance plan that your employer offers? How many have never had a test or treatment denied by your insurance company, even when your doctor urged you to have it done?
The United States spends more per capita on healthcare than any other country, and yet has higher rates of infant mortality than FORTY-ONE OTHER COUNTRIES (I got this information from that socialist hotbed of pinko propaganda, the CIA World Factbook), including paragons of progressiveness like Slovenia and, um, Cuba. Also Canada and the United Kingdom, two unfortunate nations currently languishing under a single-payer plan.
I know it's charming to believe it, but just because something is American doesn't always make it the best.
- Hilary the Touched
- Site Registrant
- Posts: 7197
- Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:11 pm
- Location: The Frozen North
- Contact:
The high US infant mortality rate maybe deceiving. We want to be heroic and did EVERYTHING trying to save a 24 weeker (costing millions for a baby who will need continuous care poss for the rest of its life.)
Some of the 'developing countries' just didn't 'count' those very immature ones as 'Infants'....they put them in a corner to die quietly since they aren't 'viable' and count them as 'miscarriage'.
The new reform needs to cap the malpractice awards or at least the lawyer fees. Healthcare cost skyrocketed because of 'defensive' medicine. If nothing was done, the cost will keep going up.
I feel angry when my patients showed up in the ER with...say..abdominal pain..and was ordered to have CT scan done to rule out ..say..acute Appendicitis...totally unnecessary if you are a good clinician. Too much $$ wasted and too much radiation .
Some of the 'developing countries' just didn't 'count' those very immature ones as 'Infants'....they put them in a corner to die quietly since they aren't 'viable' and count them as 'miscarriage'.
The new reform needs to cap the malpractice awards or at least the lawyer fees. Healthcare cost skyrocketed because of 'defensive' medicine. If nothing was done, the cost will keep going up.
I feel angry when my patients showed up in the ER with...say..abdominal pain..and was ordered to have CT scan done to rule out ..say..acute Appendicitis...totally unnecessary if you are a good clinician. Too much $$ wasted and too much radiation .
" . . . the entity currently responsible for providing care to the indigent, the U.S. military, retired military, and Congress, all of whom do currently suffer under a single-payer plan?? . . . Also Canada and the United Kingdom, two unfortunate nations currently languishing under a single-payer plan.
Hilary, I'm afraid that irony and sarcasm aren't decipherable to some. It just flies over their heads, and they think you're in agreement with them. Otherwise, your points are all well presented.
Hilary, I'm afraid that irony and sarcasm aren't decipherable to some. It just flies over their heads, and they think you're in agreement with them. Otherwise, your points are all well presented.
- Hilary the Touched
- Site Registrant
- Posts: 7197
- Joined: Sat Jul 23, 2005 2:11 pm
- Location: The Frozen North
- Contact:
Char, you raise an interesting and valid point--I wasn't aware of that.
I am aware that the issue of infant mortality is complex, and that the U.S. has led in important developments--I remember reading about the death of a child born prematurely to the Kennedys, who, before the introduction of drugs to speed lung development, just had no chance at all.
I am aware that the issue of infant mortality is complex, and that the U.S. has led in important developments--I remember reading about the death of a child born prematurely to the Kennedys, who, before the introduction of drugs to speed lung development, just had no chance at all.
-
- Posts: 2582
- Joined: Fri Nov 30, 2007 3:36 pm
- Location: Florida
And don't forget the overabundance of multiple births now. Many of these children grow up to have lifelong health problems. Most of them will receive some form of government help or the hospitals will write off a lot of care. All of this adds up.
I'm not saying that we shouldn't help these parents. I'm just adding another facet to the problem. A friends grandson was born at 2 1/2 lbs. and since neither parent had jobs or health insurance the hospital ended up graciously writing off the bill. With universal insurance this would have been unnecessary.
I'm not saying that we shouldn't help these parents. I'm just adding another facet to the problem. A friends grandson was born at 2 1/2 lbs. and since neither parent had jobs or health insurance the hospital ended up graciously writing off the bill. With universal insurance this would have been unnecessary.